openai.com — 68/100 (Risc mediu pentru confidențialitate)
Ultima analiză
OpenAI · openai.com
Detalii raport
Risc mediu pentru confidențialitatePolitica de confidențialitate a UE a OpenAI oferă controale puternice pentru utilizatori și transparență, dar este deficitară în privința minimizării datelor, clarității privind partajarea cu terțe părți și a garanțiilor pentru transferurile internaționale de date pentru utilizatorii din UE.
OpenAI’s EU privacy policy provides detailed disclosures about data collection, processing purposes, and user rights, including explicit opt-outs for model training. However, it collects broad categories of data (e.g., user content, logs, device info), shares data extensively with vendors and affiliates, and transfers data to the US and other non-EEA countries using SCCs. While it offers granular controls (e.g., temporary chats, model training opt-outs), gaps remain in data minimization, third-party subprocessor transparency, and the practical enforceability of transfer mechanisms under EU law. The policy is compliant on paper but raises concerns about proportionality and oversight.
Nu am putut traduce acest raport acum, așa că detaliile de mai jos sunt în engleză.
Evaluare pe categorii
Defalcare a politicii pe domenii cheie de conformitate. Bun = solid, rezonabil = mixt, slab = îngrijorător.
Collects extensive data (e.g., prompts, files, IP addresses, device IDs) beyond what’s strictly necessary for core functionality, though some controls (e.g., temporary chats) limit retention.
Detailed disclosures on data types, purposes, and legal bases, with clear links to help center articles and opt-out mechanisms.
Shares data broadly with vendors, affiliates, and business partners (e.g., cloud providers, payment processors) without a comprehensive, named subprocessor list or granular consent for each category.
Uses SCCs for non-EEA transfers but lacks detail on supplementary measures to address US surveillance risks, and does not restrict transfers to ‘adequate’ jurisdictions only.
Explicit opt-out for model training is available, and users can disable memory/history features to limit data used for improvements.
Clearly lists GDPR rights (access, deletion, portability, objection) and provides multiple channels (account settings, privacy portal, email) to exercise them.
Constatări cheie
Clauze notabile, probleme sau practici pozitive identificate (critice primele)
Inadequate safeguards for international transfers to the US
Section 10 confirms transfers to the US and other non-EEA countries using SCCs, but does not describe supplementary technical/organizational measures (e.g., end-to-end encryption, zero-knowledge architectures) to address US government surveillance risks. Post-Schrems II, SCCs alone are often deemed insufficient by EU courts and regulators (e.g., CNIL, EDPB).
Overly broad data collection undermines minimization
Section 1 lists extensive categories of data collected, including user content (prompts, files, images, voice/video), log data (IP, browser settings), usage data (interactions, feedback), device info, and location data. While some data is necessary for service delivery, the policy does not justify the proportionality of collecting all these categories for every user or feature. For example, location data is inferred from IP addresses ‘for security’ but also used for ‘product experience’ without clear necessity.
Lack of named subprocessor list for third-party sharing
Section 3 states data is shared with ‘vendors and service providers’ (e.g., hosting, cloud, analytics, payment processors) but does not provide a named list or link to a subprocessor registry. This omits critical transparency required under GDPR Art. 28(3) for users to assess risks of sharing with specific third parties (e.g., AWS, Stripe).
Ambiguous legal basis for model training with user content
Section 2 states user content may be used to ‘improve models’ but relies on ‘legitimate interests’ as a legal basis, which may conflict with GDPR’s requirement for explicit consent for high-risk processing (e.g., training generative AI). While an opt-out exists, the default inclusion of user content in training without clear consent is a compliance risk.
Retention periods lack specificity for certain data types
Section 4 describes retention based on ‘legitimate business purposes’ (e.g., fraud prevention, legal obligations) but does not specify maximum durations for categories like log data or usage analytics. For example, it states data may be retained ‘as long as necessary’ for security but does not define what ‘necessary’ entails for non-critical data.
Rezumat pentru utilizator
You have significant control over your data (e.g., opting out of model training, deleting chats), but OpenAI collects a wide range of personal data, shares it with many third parties, and transfers it outside the EU. If privacy is a priority, disable model training, avoid uploading sensitive files, and review third-party integrations carefully.
Postură de conformitate
The policy aligns with GDPR requirements on transparency, legal bases, and user rights, but its reliance on SCCs for non-EEA transfers and broad data sharing with vendors/affiliates may not satisfy stricter interpretations of EU data protection (e.g., Schrems II). The Irish DPC’s oversight adds credibility, but enforcement risks persist for high-risk transfers.
Transferuri UE
Data is transferred to the US and other non-EEA countries using Standard Contractual Clauses (SCCs) and, where applicable, adequacy decisions. However, the policy does not address supplementary measures (e.g., encryption, pseudonymization) to mitigate US surveillance risks under FISA 702, leaving transfers vulnerable to legal challenges under EU law. No explicit mention of Binding Corporate Rules (BCRs) or other safeguards beyond SCCs.
Semnale detectate
Date și practici specifice identificate în text
Fragmente probatorii
Citate directe din politică care susțin aceste constatări
Vi indsamler personoplysninger om dig (“Personoplysninger”) som følger: Kontooplysninger, Brugerindhold, Kommunikationsoplysninger, Kontaktdata, Andre oplysninger, du giver, Logdata, Brugsdata, Enhedsoplysninger, Lokationsoplysninger, Cookies og lignende teknologier.
Vi deler dine personoplysninger med leverandører og tjenesteudbydere, herunder udbydere af hostingtjenester, cloudtjenester, indholdsleveringstjenester, support- og sikkerhedstjenester, e-mail-kommunikationssoftware, webanalysetjenester, betalings- og transaktionsbehandlere.
OpenAI behandler dine personoplysninger på servere, der er placeret uden for EØS, Schweiz og Storbritannien... Når vi overfører personoplysninger uden for EØS, Schweiz eller Storbritannien, benytter vi gyldige overførselsmekanismer for at overholde gældende databeskyttelseslovgivning, såsom Europa-Kommissionens afgørelser om tilstrækkeligheden af databeskyttelse og standardkontraktbestemmelserne (SCC).
Vi bruger det indhold, du giver os, til at forbedre vores tjenester, for eksempel til at træne de modeller, der driver ChatGPT. Læs vores vejledning om, hvordan du kan fravælge, at vi bruger dit indhold til at træne vores modeller.
Vi opbevarer kun dine personoplysninger, så længe vi har brug for dem til at levere vores tjenester til dig, eller til andre legitime forretningsformål såsom løsning af tvister, af sikkerheds- og sikkerhedsmæssige årsager eller for at overholde vores retlige forpligtelser.
Lipsă sau neclar
- No named list of subprocessors (vendors/service providers) with roles and locations
- No detail on supplementary technical measures for international transfers (e.g., encryption, pseudonymization)
- No explicit restriction on data retention periods for non-critical data (e.g., logs, analytics)
- No clarity on whether ‘legitimate interests’ for model training meets GDPR’s high bar for consent in AI contexts
- No disclosure of data subject to US government requests (e.g., FISA 702) or how such requests are handled
- No information on Binding Corporate Rules (BCRs) or other transfer mechanisms beyond SCCs
Întrebări de pus
- Can OpenAI provide a full, up-to-date list of all subprocessors (including sub-subprocessors) involved in processing EU user data, with their locations and roles?
- What supplementary technical measures (e.g., end-to-end encryption, zero-knowledge proofs) does OpenAI implement to protect EU data transferred to the US from government surveillance?
- Does OpenAI obtain explicit consent (not just an opt-out) for using user content to train models, given the high-risk nature of generative AI under GDPR?
- How long does OpenAI retain log data, usage analytics, and device identifiers for users who are not under active investigation or legal hold?
- What specific legal bases apply to the collection of location data, contact data, and device identifiers, and how are these justified as necessary?
- How does OpenAI ensure that vendors/service providers (e.g., cloud providers) do not access or use EU user data for their own purposes (e.g., model training)?
- Has OpenAI conducted a Data Protection Impact Assessment (DPIA) for its model training practices, and can it be shared with regulators or users upon request?
Distribuie această analiză
Oricine are acest link poate vedea rezultatul de mai sus.
Creat de DentroChat
Chat AI 100% european pentru toți
Discută cu AI, lucrează cu fișiere, generează imagini și caută pe web. Datele rămân în Europa.
Alte politici de confidențialitate analizate
Vezi toaterobotstxt.es
68/100
Risc mediu pentru confidențialitateRobotstxt respectă în general confidențialitatea UE, dar lipsesc detalii clare cu privire la bazele legale, procesatorii terți și utilizarea inteligenței artificiale.
Vezi raportul →fenritec.eu
68/100
Risc mediu pentru confidențialitateFenritec respectă în general regulile de confidențialitate din UE, dar lipsesc limite clare privind utilizarea datelor pentru inteligență artificială (AI), dezvăluirea proactivă a sub-procesatorilor și declarații detaliate de minimizare a datelor.
Vezi raportul →bestalternatives.eu
65/100
Risc mediu pentru confidențialitateBest European Alternatives minimizează cu adevărat datele și evită cookie-urile, dar folosește procesatori cu sediul în SUA fără a aborda măsurile de protecție pentru transferurile internaționale și omite drepturi esențiale prevăzute de RGPD și detalii legale.
Vezi raportul →calendly.com
65/100
Risc mediu pentru confidențialitateCalendly colectează o gamă largă de date personale și de utilizare, le partajează cu parteneri de publicitate și, deși oferă drepturi standard UE și mecanisme de transfer, perioadele sale vagi de retenție și tăcerea privind instruirea AI pentru funcția sa Notetaker sunt îngrijorătoare.
Vezi raportul →